
Music Therapy
Years ago, I learned the value of music in therapy when I was working at an independent living facility. This placement was for young adults with learning disabilities, and when I realized I wasn’t able to make any progress with them, I opted to have some fun singing karaoke. So, I set up the machine, began to sing, and one by one, all of the clients showed up, sang, and had the time of their lives! After two years, I finally found a way to connect with them, and from that point on, I made real progress. It was obvious from the start that music can open doors and truly help people who struggle with mental illness and substance abuse.
Karaoke singing has helped me learn a lot about my clients. You can plainly see if they are confident, if they make excuses, if they hide behind others, if they refuse to participate, or if they are confident. Then, how do I get people to break free from their doubts, embarrassment, overwhelm, and fear of judgment? There is no formula, so I model the behavior by getting up there and singing. This breaks the ice, lets them see that “sober activities” can be fun, and that no matter what other people think or do, it doesn’t have to stop them from having fun.
If somebody is petrified and refusing to participate, I often look to the people in the group to persuade them. If this fails to work, I tend to put on a fun song that the entire group will sing. Nine times out of ten, they will sing along—and when they do, they tend to keep singing, because it’s fun!
This past week, karaoke was more prevalent. It goes like that—sometimes we won’t sing for months, and other weeks it can be almost daily. I felt bad for one new client because they were already timid and had some paranoia, but music can work very well with this type. You could see that when they realized every person in the group was expected to sing, they vehemently objected. Like I always do, I kidded the group that singing was mandatory if they wanted to discharge from the IOP program. So, like usual, I got up first, showed my confidence, and sang my heart out. Then the next participant, who was actually a professional singer, showed his talent—and boy, what a talent. He had my jaw dropping! Then it was time for the newbie to grab the microphone.
“Oh no, I just can’t do this. I’ll watch,” they said with an uncomfortable smile.
“No, you get to go now,” I said with all the kindness I could muster. Since he hadn’t picked a song, I did what I normally do and put on a children’s song—“I’ve Been Working on the Railroad.” And yes, I know it’s cheesy, but it really is fun to sing. Soon the staff and other clients began singing, and much to all our joy, so did Mister Reluctant. We all cheered our approval! Before long, he was singing with a smile.
One engineering-type client didn’t sing for weeks and initially missed group because of his fear. Then one day, he reported that he was bored and was just there to watch—so I decided to choose a song for him. He couldn’t resist the urge to participate when “Born to Be Wild” came on. After that, he sang every song (I mean every song) until he left the program! To me, this was a triumph. How often do we challenge ourselves and break through our self-imposed limitations? We are either externally locused or internally locused. Since we lack the ability to change other people, it’s important to work on changing ourselves.
Group therapy is the best thing we offer. Individual sessions are good, and so are family sessions, but the influence of a group has been incredible. On our own, we can only go so far—but with the support of a group, we can take those extra steps that help us get to the finish line. Group therapy is known for creating a sense of belonging, giving and receiving support, reassurance that you are not alone in your suffering and that problems can be universal. It helps reduce feelings of isolation, provides opportunities for personal growth, increases accountability, creates friendships, and helps gain new perspectives on coping strategies. I have found that group therapy is more effective in our practice because of the time factor. Having 3-hour sessions instead of one hour helps provide the time to explain an approach, have participants practice the approach on each other, and, in a sense, learn how to be a therapist to themselves for the long term.
Karaoke singing has become an intricate part of the groups. The rule is: there are no put-downs—only support. Of course, this can be a difficult rule to follow, because I have heard some of the worst singing on the planet. But karaoke singing is not about the singing; it’s about the effort. Some of the learning-disabled clients were unaware of how horrible they sounded. To them, they were Madonna or Eminem, and they had the time of their lives. I wasn’t going to tell them they sounded like a toad—even though they did.
Life can be hard for someone with a learning disability because they are aware of their limitations and have to try to hide them on a daily basis just to fit in. But when a group of people is cheering them on, as we do with karaoke, they get to go on vacation from themselves and be proud of their efforts.
I left this facility and took my karaoke machine with me to the Mental Health Urgent Care Center. It was a crisis center for people who had no insurance or federal insurance. These people were mostly schizophrenic, but I didn’t care. It was a rare Sunday shift for me, and we rarely saw more than 10 people. So, I set up the machine in the waiting room and tried to entice the clients and our staff to join in, but many of my coworkers balked, saying they had to get drunk to do so. That was an interesting comment. Don’t mental health workers work on their own issues? We sure did in graduate school. The premise was: if we were struggling with an issue and a client came in with that same difficulty, we’d get triggered. I worked hard in graduate school during the four years I attended the University of Santa Monica. All the sessions we conducted on each other proved to be invaluable when I began treating others.
My coworkers on that day refused to sing because they said they had to get drunk. Whatever. I decided to go alone and found a willing participant who came to our facility to renew their antipsychotic medication. Little did I know that this person had real talent and sang like an angel! Even the staff came out to witness her. Not so bad. A person goes into a free clinic, fills out paperwork, meets with a nurse to take their vitals and take a history, meets with me, gets some self-help tools, sings karaoke, and then meets with a psychiatrist for a few minutes before they are given a prescription or some sample medication. Some are even given lunch if they are hungry.
Today, at Basic Steps Mental Health, I have seen over 700 people in the seven years we have been open. Unlike the Urgent Care Center, where I only saw a person once or twice, I have one person I have seen 175 times — basically once a week since we started. This is rare, since mostly I will see a person about eight times. The long-term clients just like to come in for emotional support and simply talk to a neutral person who won’t use their information against them.
I haven’t tried doing karaoke singing with individuals yet. I have played them a song I composed on my guitar, if I am proud of something hot off the shelf, but no — individual therapy is a different beast that I am sure I will write about at some point, if I haven’t already.
Alternative treatments may be more important than what is standard in the industry because it touches more of an emotional part inside. In combination with what is standard, it works out best, but music can break down walls and form wonderful bonds that are needed in treatment.
This article brought up some frustration I have had recently in regards to treatment options, so I will go with what presents itself. Not a salesman, I find it difficult to promote my IOP program to the people who need it the most. There have been more severe types signing up for treatment as of late, and all are opting to go through individual therapy. Knowing the value of the groups and the positive impact they make on serious abuse, addiction, and panic disorders, impacting a life change one hour a week or one hour a month is like putting out a raging fire with a squirt gun. How many hours are there in a week? One hour is not going to do much, but why are these people shortchanging themselves? Is it because suffering is familiar? Maybe it is the time commitment? Our IOP program runs three times a week and three hours per session. Four weeks to change the rest of your life versus the ongoing agony seems like a no-brainer. And yes, I also know that $3,600 is a lot of money, but we take monthly payments as low as $300 a month. Stopping an addictive pattern will equal that cost in a year.
Opting to save time and money versus properly addressing agony, pain, hiding alone in bed all week, or being stuck in an addiction that is killing you — well, you choose. If you have a problem, go after it. Instead of running away, like many tried to do in karaoke singing, face it—and face it with support from a staff that has been there and done that.
Each staff member at Basic Steps has gone through our IOP program and used the tools they are presenting. This is why we all have faith in what we are presenting — because it has worked for us all. This is not the 12 steps of AA; it is a psychological program that heals issues at the root. And yes, heals. Thirty years and counting, and I am still not sick of presenting this Spiritual Psychology approach. Aren’t you sick and tired of being sick and tired? I love treating those who have tried numerous programs in the past because our program is a program, and each day builds upon itself. (Please read our reviews.)
We have a new intern who just went through her first day at the facility and said she has had five placements, and this makes the others look foolish. Our program puts psychology into action; theirs was book information and non-involvement. Ours honors people, gives them a voice, and touches each person where tears are common. Theirs doesn’t interest a soul. She is excited about learning the true craft of psychotherapy at our facility, and after one day there, she was hooked.
Compassionate Care is Always Available
There are many more tools and strategies you can use in your pursuit of happiness. Here is where we come in. Contact us at Basic Steps Mental Health and let us support and educate you on this journey back to your loving heart center. Imagine living a heart-centered life, regardless of what is happening externally. We’d love to be of help.
For 25 years, Dr. Scott Alpert, the clinical director of Basic Steps Mental Health, has treated over 7,000 people with mental health and addiction problems, using a Psychological approach that mixes and matches ten of the top approaches used in the industry. We are here virtually and in-person to help you get through this COVID-19 pandemic and many other difficulties you may be experiencing.
May you have good mental health.
Related Posts
Reframing – A Positive Twist
Reframing is a major tool that helps to keep me centered. Reframing is...
Virtual Therapy
In 1994 I began treating people with substance abuse and mental illness problems....